
This is not a review, it may have some small semblance of being a review but at the heart of it, it isn’t. I have wanted to read Black Swan Rising for a few months now, not only was the cover amazing, but it was urban fantasy and sounded like it could be amazing. When I found it at the library, I was beyond happy, I borrowed the book and went home.
This happened yesterday, and from my tone I think you can tell that I was disappointed. Beyond disappointed. I didn’t understand how such a promising book could have such flaws. I’m only going to discuss the first chapter and part of the second at the moment because I have a few nit-picks and haven’t yet finished the book.
Let’s begin with the constant emphasis on location. It seems the authors are trying to launch the fact that its set in Manhattan down our throats, on the first page alone they say, ‘I knew the village like the back of my hand. I grew up in a town house in the West Village.’ ‘lower Manhattan in a daze’, ‘Hudson River’, ‘West Village’, ‘Tribeca’, ‘Canal Street’ and the ‘Hudson’ again. Of course, location is important to a book, but from this first page I was disinterested as the reader. It was nice that the authors understood the importance of location, but it wasn’t required every few lines.
Another problem with this first page is that the authors make everything plainly obvious. Once again I use the line, ‘I knew the village like the back of my hand,’ before resorting to telling us on the next page that she doesn’t know where she is. How convenient for the storyline, (it’s also convenient that in the next chapter she types ‘Symbols.com’ into the search bar and discovers a symbol immediately.) Garet doesn’t know where she is, go into the shop and reveal things about yourself to a strange old man, and he just happens to offer you $1,000. And you’re in debt! Even more convenient.
From here we move onto the info-dumping, grotesquely-long descriptions:
‘It was an antiques store, that much was clear from the contents of the window – Georgian silver, sapphire and diamond rings, gold pocket watches – all beautiful, but a bit too precious for my taste. Peering through the glass door, I saw that the shop itself looked like a tiny jewel box, the walls panelled in dark wood, the sparkling glass cases lined with garnet-coloured velvet, a curtain of wine-coloured damask hanging behind a polished mahogany counter carved in sinuous art-nouveau curves.’
And later on in Chapter Two:
‘I lifted the box, still in its velvet sack, out of my bag and carried it over to my worktable, which stood at the far end of the room near the floor-to-ceiling windows under the slanted sky-light that faced the garden. In the daytime the light poured in through the south-facing windows, making it the ideal workspace. An old secretary desk fit into a small alcove to the right making supplies and the scrap metal I collected for my metal sculptures. One of those sculptures, a six-foot long dragon crafted of junk metal and chain links, hung from a hook in the ceiling. In the daytime his red headlight eyes caught the sun and gleamed mischievously, but tonight he cast a looming shadow against the rain-speckled windows that made me feel vaguely uneasy.’
The description here appears clunky and out of place, the writers should space out their descriptions, placing it within the sentences, so that the reader doesn’t have to feel like they’re wading their way through tar. This description is an info-dump and the reader doesn’t need to know all of this information. It’s great that the writers understand what their character’s house looks like, but there are better ways to show this information.
Another problem I have is with the lack of showing the characters emotions, I don’t care that this is the first person, we should be told how Garet feels about the debt. Everything I’ve read so far reads as though the writers are being completely self-indulgent – regaling us with a synopsis of what’s happened in Garet’s life.
Plus the first two chapters are filled with clichés. Garet’s mother once told her, ‘A rare bird on earth, very much like the black swan. That’s what you are, Garet, a rare bird. Unique. Don’t ever let anyone make you think you have to be the same as everyone else.’ Who doesn’t enjoy a nice bit of cliché-fuelled drivel that’s so cheesy you’re practically vomiting? So Garet’s special. A Mary-Sue! How brilliantly amazing!
Then she meets the antiques dealer who just happens to have a box with a symbol that matches her ring, but he can’t open it, perhaps she, as a jeweller, could do so. He’ll pay her $1,000 to do so! Convenient and cliché. Every problem is too easily fixed and never seems like a problem.
I just hope this book gets better, and I’ll continue to post as I go along.
More of a rant than a review really.
Until next time, that is all.